Personal Experience: Change brokerage from RBC&TD to interactive broker
I just want to share my personal experience change brokerage from RBC&TD to interactive broker since late 2019. I found interactive broker much better than TD/RBC for my US equity investment. I invest predominantly in US stocks, including Canadian companies dual listed in NYSE/NASDAQ. Some of the big Pros:
Very low commission compared to RBC/TD. 1USD for fixed pricing, 0.35 for tired pricing.
Participation in pre-market and after-market. This help me to fill my aggressive limit order.
USD/CAD forex is 2USD, even cheaper than Nombert Gambit.
Fractional shares allow me to invest in Google/Amazon/Tesla in a more reasonable pace.(buy 500 dollars for four times vs buy 2000 at one time)
They have several platforms which is very confusing. TWS is most powerful but look ugly on Mac. Client portal is nice looking but function-lacking. I actually found IBKR IOS to be powerful but also nice looking, so end up mostly use IBKR IOS.
Be careful using EFT deposit. There is a 60 business day holding period if withdrawal to a different bank.
One might need to spend some time research on their fee structure, deposit/withdrawal procedure.
I have ignored IB for years due to it being an American brokerage and do not have physical locations. Finally tried it and now think it is the best for US equity investment in Canada. Hopefully if we move more investment to online brokerage such as Questrade/IB/Wealthsimple, eventually will shake the big 5 and force them to lower their ridiculous commission.(It is still nice to have one of the big 5 for some portfolio.)
Are you new here? Want to know where to start? Don't understand why something happened? START HERE!
Hello and welcome to The /Forex Trading Community!
Please do not post a new thread until you have read through our WIKI/FAQ. It is highly likely that your questions are already answered there. All members are expected to follow our sidebar rules. Some rules have a zero tolerance policy, so be sure to read through them to avoid being perma-banned without the ability to appeal. (Mobile users, click the info tab at the stop of our subreddit to view the sidebar rules.) Don't forget to join us in our live trading chatroom! *Finally, *the most commonly posted questions by new members are as followed: What is a good broker to use? We have some great info on brokers listed in our wiki:
What is the best prop / scouting firm for forex? FXGears.com has a great writeup on forex prop / scouting firms that can be found here. What just happened in the markets? - You must follow an economic calendar if you're a currency trader. This will explain many events and snap market moves. You can find links to resources and calendars here. - Again, questions of this nature will be removed. If you have any questions regarding our policies, rules, etc.. please message the mods. Be friendly and professional toward each other and enjoy your stay! :)
How-to & FAQ for holding Bitcoin and Ethereum in an RRSP/TFSA
A few months ago I came across a way to hold crypto in my RRSP/TFSA and have been answering questions about how to do that in comments, DM's, and Skype consults. I figured it would be helpful to put together one big comprehensive FAQ. Cryptocurrency is treated as a commodity by the CRA and you must pay capital gains taxes on any profits if held outside a TFSA. If bitcoin goes to $1m as some are predicting, the Canadian government is going to be taxing a huge windfall in capital gains taxes. BACKGROUND Bitcoin & other crypto cannot be held directly in a RRSP/TFSA, and there are no eligible ETF's in North America yet. However, the ETN COINXBT which trades on the Stockholm Stock Exchange in Sweden (Nasdaq Stockholm) is eligible. ABOUT COINXBT COINXBT holds bitcoin directly and its price per share is based on a 0.005 multiple of the current bitcoin price. For example, if the current price of bitcoin is $10000USD, a share of COINXBT will be worth $50USD (ie: $493 Swedish Kroner) Company's website and full prospectus at: https://xbtprovider.com/ Price quote / chart: https://www.bloomberg.com/quote/COINXBT:SS HOW-TO TRADE Only some Canadian brokerages allow you to trade on eligible international exchanges in your TFSA. Some do not. Typically placing trades on international exchanges online is not an option and must be made over the phone broker-assisted at a much higher cost than typical North American securities. CANADIAN BROKERS I've called pretty much every brokerage to inquire if international securities can be held in a TFSA and what the fee is to transact. You may want to call yourself to see if policies have changed, but here's a summary:
National Bank: $75 per trade + $0.06 per share (confirmed works)
TD: Fee dependent on amount traded. Up to $5K is $187, $80K would be $520 per trade (confirmed works)
CIBC: $250 minimum, based on trade amount. $50K would be about $350 to buy and $350 to sell (confirmed works)
Scotia iTrade: $250 CAD per trade CAD, unlimited shares & order size (should work)
BMO Investorline: Fee-based on total trade amount. $50K would be $325 to buy $225 to sell, $50-$60K would be $350 to buy $240 to sell (should work)
Not available, or not available in RRSP/TFSA:
Interactive Brokers, can trade it, but not in RRSP/TFSA
HSBC (has access to almost every exchange other than Stockholm)
FAQ's Are you sure it's legal? I'm quite sure it's illegal.
I used National Bank Direct Brokerage. The fee's came out to $75 per trade + $0.06 per share. For example, the commission for a trade I did for 885 shares of COINXBT was $75 + $53.10 for a total of $128.10. Canadian funds were used to make the purchase and there were no forex fees for converting to Swedish Kroner (SEK)
How do I make a trade once I'm ready?
Call your brokerage and say you want to place a trade on the Stockholm stock exchange. You may be forwarded to a person that specializes in that, and eventually to a broker that deals with placing order on international exchanges. Tell them the symbol to trade is COINXBT and the name of the ETN is "Bitcoin Tracker One".
How do I calculate the number of shares to trade to max out my TFSA?
The price of COINXBT is in SEK. In my case using NB I took my balance minus anticipated fees divided by the current price to see how many shares I could buy. For example: For a $10,000 TFSA, current COINXBT price = $554.77SEK (84.27CAD), would be 117 shares at a cost of $9859.59 + $82.02 commission for a total of $9941.61CAD
Market or Limit order?
The first time I placed an order for COINXBT I tried to place a limit order a little below the market price. Over the next week the price of bitcoin ran up a lot and didn't come down. I ended up buying a lot higher. Since then I've been placing limit orders slightly above the current price or just market orders so that they go through right away. I've had no issues doing it either way.
When can I trade? Is it only possible to make the trade while the Swedish market is open and the TSX are open at the same time? Or can you place the order at any time of day?
XBT Provider has said they will monitor forks for 3-months and then decide what action to take. In the case of Bitcoin Cash, they sold the forked coins and distributed it as a dividend to anyone that held ETN shares on the fork date.
What about other cryptocurrencies?
An ethereum ETN was recently launched: COINETH that also trades on the Stockholm exchange. https://www.bloomberg.com/quote/COINETH:SS Other than that, I am not aware of any other eligible crypto securities that can be held in a RRSP/TFSA
How is the price of COINXBT determined?
It's based on the average price of the top 3 exchanges
Why not just buy GBTC?
GBTC is traded on the OTC exchange in the US and is not RRSP/TFSA eligible
Why can't I place a trade online myself?
For now, there are no crypto ETF's on North American exchanges. They have been in the works for years in the US, but no approvals yet. Evolve funds recently said they plan to launch a Canadian Bitcoin ETF. Trading COINXBT is a bit of a hassle, but you're getting in ahead of everyone else that are not willing to put in the time/effort. Once the Canadian/US ETF launches, it will probably be worth it to sell COINXBT and switch to the North American one which should be easy to trade online just like other ETF's.
Feedback If you've managed to get crypto into your RRSP/TFSA in any other ways than listed above please do leave a comment and I'll update the post. Thanks!
Coinexx.com is one of the new- gen hybrid Crypto Forex Broker. They offer Forex CFDs, Commodities, Indies and Crypto pairs for trading. The competitive spreads, low commissions and good trading conditions are getting the broker rave reviews. Coinexx doesn’t require any identity verification for traders to set up an account. The broker has a strict “no fiat” policy meaning you cannot deposit in traditional fiat currencies. They offer 25 crypto currencies to deposit and withdraw at no cost. The deposits are auto & instant and withdrawals within 24 hours. They offer both metatrader platforms, i.e. MT4 and MT5 to clients to trade on their ECN account. The traders can choose between a BTC, BCC, LTC, USD and ETH base currency account. What Stands Out - Any to Any deposit & withdrawals between 25 altcoins -Tight Spreads- 500X leverage and leveraged crypto pairs -Commission at just $2 per lot, lowest from our list of brokers - No Verification Anonymous Account Opening - Accepts US clients, Canadian Clients and is NON ESMA - Live Chat Support 24/5 (unusual for a Crypto Broker) - Trust Factor – 5/5 stars Con – MT4 Missing. The broker argues that since Meta Quotes will not be updating MT4 and all ultimately MT4 brokers will have to transition to MT5 so they decided to offer MT5 only. More of their business decision not a Con per say. [Update: Coinexx is now offering MT4 platform to traders] Scam Alert – NIL PS: the review is based on facts collected from internet as well as other forums and after testing the broker's live account by our moderators. Let us know what you think about the broker in the comments below and/or if you hold a different view that what has been said above. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Breaking News: Coinexx acquired FinPro Trading. What does this mean for FinPro Trading traders? You will continue to trade on the same MT4 trading terminal that you are currently using at Finpro, with your existing MT4 login ID/Password. The commission charges will continue to be the same while the spreads will become better than what they used to be at Finpro.
Trader’s Way is based in Dominica and offers Forex, Commodities and Indies on MT4,MT5 and cTrader. You have choice of 4 accounts with them with no minimum deposit requirement. They offer both fixed and variable spreads and the commission and leverage vary according to the account you choose. The lowest commission being zero and leverage being 10X is and the highest commission being $2.5 per 100k and leverage 1000:1, respectively. The broker stand out in the list of payment methods they offer clients for deposits. However, there are heavy fees on depositing and withdrawing with them. What stands out? Minimum deposit only $1 High Leverage Platform Choice – MT4, MT5, cTrader Multiple deposit and withdrawal methods Accepts US, Canadian and is NON ESMA Trust factor- 4/5 Cons- Poor client support High Deposit and withdrawal charges Scam alert- NIL PS- The review is based on facts collected from internet as well as other forums and after testing the broker's Demo by our moderators. Let us know what you think about the broker in the comments below and/or if you hold a different view that what has been said above.
Interest is not limited to just Forex brokers or the FX market but to Canada’s currency as well – the Canadian Dollar (or CAD), which is considered a major currency by all Forex brokers and traders in the FX market. The well-developed economy of Canada provides a path for financial markets, e-commerce, and online businesses to traverse, therefore making the Canadian Dollar a lucrative ... Recommended Canadian Forex Brokers for Canadian Traders. This guarantees that we can promote and showcase the best Forex brokers, safe in the knowledge that you, as a Canadian citizen, are going to get a completely hassle free and first class trading experience. Avatrade – Avatrade is incorporated and regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland, the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive of ... Nonetheless, major brokers like FXCM and Forex.com have chosen to set up offices there so that they can cater to the needs of their Canadian clients better. A number of regulated forex brokers like HYCM also accept clients from Canada. * InvestTechFX and Fx Clearing claim to be Canadian forex brokers, but they are not CIPF members. Best Canadian Forex Brokers for 2020. To find the best forex brokers in Canada, we created a list of all IIROC authorised firms, then ranked brokers by their Trust Score. Here is our list of the top Canadian forex brokers. CMC Markets - Best web platform, most currency pairs; Interactive Brokers - Best for professionals; FOREX.com - Great platforms and pricing; Best Forex Brokers Canada ... Find the most complete list of Best Canadian Forex Brokers in 2020. Choose Regulated Forex company in Canada. Here’s our list of the best Canadian forex brokers. Open an account. 79% of retail investor accounts lose money. Read full review + Add to compare. 1. AvaTrade. More than just one of the best forex brokers Canada has to offer, Avatrade is respected around the world. They are IIROC regulated, and the Canadian arm of this top global broker, Avatrade Canada provides access to the same depth of ... Despite the perks, there aren't that much Canada - based forex brokers, since Canadian citizens are not limited to trade only with their local brokers, but can trade with any off-shore company they wish to. That being said, if you still wish to seek a Canadian one, there are major brokers who do have representative offices in the country to be able to serve Canadian customers better. Canada is ...
All about ForexMetatraderBrokers - List of Canadian Forex ...
CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFO: https://rebrand.ly/forex33 And start earning in the Forex Market Now! In our growing international business setting, there are firm... CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFO: https://rebrand.ly/forex33 And start earning in the Forex Market Now! In our expanding multinational business atmosphere, there are... Here is list of top true ECN brokers for forex and CFDs Trading from https://fxdailyreport.com/true-ecn-forex-brokers/ Canadian Binary Options Trading List of Best Canadian Binary Options Brokers 2014 - The binary options brokers is designed to guide binary options traders in their quest to find the right forex ... CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFO: https://rebrand.ly/forex33 And start earning in the Forex Market Now! In our expanding multinational corporate atmosphere, there ar... CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFO: https://rebrand.ly/forex33 And start earning in the Forex Market Now! In our expanding multinational company setting, there are com... Best Stock Broker Canada 2018 is here to help you pick the right stock broker for you. I made a Best Broker of 2018 for my USA viewers, but my Canadian viewers don't have the same options and I ... If you’re a Forex trader, then today’s video is for you. Because you’re about to discover the truth about Forex brokers that nobody tells you. And once you’v... http://bestforexbrokersonline.blogspot.com list best forex brokers canada